Luke 17:7ExegesisTAB

Luke 17 : 7 Service | Obligation | Expectation
7. Linguistic Exegesis
The verse begins with the interrogative tis {Τίς | Tís} ‘who?’ followed by the postpositive de {δὲ | dè} ‘but, and’, forming a rhetorical question that appeals directly to the hearers. The prepositional phrase ex humōn {ἐξ ὑμῶν | éx hū-môn} ‘from among you’ foregrounds the audience as the frame of reference. The construction doulon ekhōn arotriōnta ē poimainonta {δοῦλον ἔχων ἀροτριῶντα ἢ ποιμαίνοντα | doû-lon é-khōn a-ro-tri-ônta ē poi-maí-non-ta} consists of a head noun “servant” modified by the nominative participle ekhōn ‘having’ and two accusative participles that specify the servant’s typical work (plowing or shepherding). The relative pronoun hos {ὃς | hòs} introduces a clause that further characterizes this hypothetical master: hos eiselthonti ek tou agrou eipē autō {ὃς εἰσελθόντι ἐκ τοῦ ἀγροῦ εἴπῃ αὐτῷ | hòs ei-sel-thón-ti ek tou a-grou eíp-ē au-tō̂}. Here, the dative participle eiselthonti ‘when he has come in’ functions temporally in relation to the finite verb eipē, and is linked semantically with autō ‘to him,’ depicting the moment when the servant returns from the field. The aorist subjunctive eipē in a rhetorical question presents a potential action as unlikely: “would he say…?” Direct speech follows, introduced without a verb of saying, consisting of an adverb–participle–imperative chain: Eutheōs parelthōn anapese {Εὐθέως παρελθὼν ἀνάπεσε | eu-thé-ōs pa-rel-thṓn a-ná-pe-se}. The adverb eutheōs ‘immediately’ modifies the participle parelthōn ‘having come (over, here),’ which in turn is subordinate to the main command anapese ‘recline.’ This creates an idiomatic command, “Come at once and recline,” reflecting ancient dining practice of reclining at table. In English, the participial constructions are rendered as temporal (“when he comes in”) and as part of a natural imperative (“Come immediately and recline” / “Sit down to eat immediately”) to preserve the rhetorical force and cultural nuance while avoiding awkward literalism.

More on this verse