Matthew 17:4ExegesisTAB

Matthew 17 : 4 Presence | Worship | Authority
4. Linguistic Exegesis
The aorist participle apokritheis {ἀποκριθεὶς | a-po-kri-theìs} “having answered” frames Peter’s response as a narrative backdrop leading to the main verb eipen {εἶπεν | eî-pen} “he said.” The articular proper name ho Petros {ὁ Πέτρος | ho Pé-tros} identifies the subject, and the dative article-object construction tō Iesou {τῷ Ἰησοῦ | tô Iē-soû} marks Jesus as the addressee. The vocative Kyrie {Κύριε | Ký-ri-e} expresses direct address and reverence. In the clause Kalon estin hēmas hôde eî-nai {καλόν ἐστιν ἡμᾶς ὧδε εἶναι | ka-lón é-stin hē-mâs hô-de eî-nai}, the predicate adjective kalon “good” precedes the impersonal verb estin and the infinitive phrase “for us to be here,” emphasizing Peter’s positive evaluation of the mountain setting. The conditional protasis ei theleis {εἰ θέλεις | ei thé-leis} “if You wish” conveys deference to Jesus’ will, while the subjunctive poiēso {ποιήσω | poi-ḗ-sō} “I may make” indicates an offer rather than assertion. The repetition of the adverb hô-de “here” focuses attention on the location. The tricolon treis skēnas … soi mian, Mōusei mian, Ēlia mian {τρεῖς σκηνὰς … σοὶ μίαν, Μωϋσεῖ μίαν, Ἠλίᾳ μίαν | treîs skē-nàs … soì mí-an, Mō-ü-seî mí-an, Ē-lí-ai mí-an} balances three parallel proposals, underscoring Peter’s desire to honor each figure equally and reflecting his misunderstanding of Jesus’ unique status.

More on this verse